Skip to main content

Table 2 Comparison of field-based and remote-sensing based AGB values in the community forests in Kayar Khola watershed in 2009 and 2012 and change over time

From: Synergizing community-based forest monitoring with remote sensing: a path to an effective REDD+ MRV system

No

CF name

No. of field sample plots used

Field based AGB

RS based AGB

Total 2009 (ton)

Av. 2009 (ton/ha)

Total 2012 (ton)

Av. 2012 (ton/ha)

Annual change (ton)

Annual change/ton/ha

Total 2009 (ton)

Av. 2009 (ton/ha)

Total 2012 (ton)

Av. 2012 (ton/ha)

Annual change (ton)

Annual change/ton/ha

1

Batauli

11

3873.15

352.10

3895.23

354.11

7.36

0.67

3883.26

353.02

3917.06

356.10

11.27

1.02

2

Chitramkaminchuli

8

1639.53

204.94

1852.50

231.56

70.99

8.87

1664.86

208.11

1873.62

234.20

69.58

8.70

3

Deujar

9

3016.15

335.13

3075.33

341.70

19.73

2.19

3051.04

339.00

3104.26

344.92

17.74

1.97

4

Devidhunga

29

12,931.54

445.92

12,990.13

447.94

19.53

0.65

12,982.21

447.66

13,235.16

456.38

84.32

2.91

5

Dharapani

13

5361.57

412.43

5421.76

417.06

20.06

1.54

5428.09

417.55

5488.97

422.23

20.29

1.56

6

Indreni

6

2110.68

351.78

2187.88

364.65

25.73

4.29

2143.34

357.22

2205.79

367.63

20.82

3.47

7

Jamuna

3

1108.11

369.37

1118.03

372.68

3.31

1.10

1111.42

370.47

1133.41

377.80

7.33

2.44

8

Janapragati

7

1747.81

249.69

1819.56

259.94

23.92

3.42

1765.87

252.27

1852.81

264.69

28.98

4.14

9

Jharana

5

2013.51

402.70

2031.35

406.27

5.95

1.19

2020.88

404.18

2038.34

407.67

5.82

1.16

10

Kalika

7

2355.69

336.53

2383.48

340.50

9.26

1.32

2392.01

341.72

2434.02

347.72

14.00

2.00

11

Kankali

4

927.68

231.92

947.41

236.85

6.58

1.64

975.08

243.77

983.36

245.84

2.76

0.69

12

Nibuwatar

21

8900.92

423.85

9083.08

432.53

60.72

2.89

8942.85

425.85

9080.94

432.43

46.03

2.19

13

Pragati

7

1899.60

271.37

1951.34

278.76

17.25

2.46

1969.84

281.41

2004.77

286.40

11.64

1.66

14

Samfrang

6

2454.06

409.01

2463.94

410.66

3.29

0.55

2443.32

407.22

2481.75

413.63

12.81

2.14

15

Satkanya

4

1079.22

269.80

1112.74

278.18

11.17

2.79

1102.71

275.68

1139.99

285.00

12.43

3.11

Total

140

51,419.22

337.77

52,333.75

344.89

20.32

2.37

51,876.78

341.67

52,974.26

349.51

24.39

2.61

  1. RMS error between field and RS based AGB Annual change/ton/ha = 0.95